Recently I wrote about the Smyth Ute, a weld-free kit car that will convert your Mk4 or Mk5 VW Jetta into a sharp little pickup truck, or “ute” as the Aussies like to call them. But is it a REAL truck? It’s front wheel drive, which already makes the claim a bit dubious. But the original Volkswagen truck was also front wheel drive, and the new Honda Ridgeline, though all wheel drive, sends most of its power to the front wheels. Will it haul stuff? Yes – the aluminum bed that comes with the kit is rated for 750lbs of cargo. So I asked the question I always seem to ask when it comes to determining any particular vehicle’s level of awesomeness: Will it rally?

Read on Right Foot Down or continue below

One of my students at last month’s MassTuning Trackfest was Michael Gallant, who, along with Mark Smith, actually designed Smyth Ute kit. He had hoped to drive his own Smyth Ute on the track but it wasn’t quite ready in time, so he drove his Scion FR-S instead. Naturally, our similar cars made us fast friends. I told him about the New England Region SCCA rallycross taking place at the same track the following weekend. He promptly got hooked, and offered to let me co-drive his Ute at this month’s event in Vermont. I’ve been fascinated by the Smyth Ute ever since I first learned about it, and jumped at the opportunity to not only check one out for myself, but to drive it at speed. How much does cutting 1/4 of the car away affect its handling and classic German solid feeling chassis?

Surprisingly, it actually improves it. According to Michael, the Mk4 Jetta Ute is about 200lbs lighter than the original car, since the doors and other parts of the car that get removed are quite heavy. This weight reduction in the rear improves handling, making the car more neutral than biased toward understeer. It didn’t take much left foot braking at all to make the Ute rotate, and with practice it was quite easy to control.

Advertisement

But the biggest surprise to me was the Ute’s rigidity. Any German car I’ve ever driven or ridden in has a distinct German feel to it, regardless of which German manufacturer built it, thanks to their over engineered platforms. Despite cutting away the top rear quarter of the Jetta, it still feels just as solid and just as German as before. The Smyth Ute adds many structural components, including the bed itself, which keep what’s left of the car tied together just as well as before you cut the roof and trunk off. For me, the rigidity was the biggest surprise of them all.

Thanks to this and a good set of snow tires, yes, the Smyth Ute absolutely will rally – or at least rallycross. Classing is tricky for any kind of actual competition, since removing such a large portion of the car is generally illegal in any class. We voluntarily ran in Exhibition class as a result, but have since been invited to run in Modified FWD by the many competitors in that class. They seem to think the Smyth Ute is cool, and certainly within the spirit of the MF rules if not the letter. Our times would have placed us 7th and 9th in the class, so we’re no threat to the front runners – yet…

Oh, speaking of times… Neither Michael nor I believe that a co-driver shouldn’t beat the owner of the car, so with that mutual understanding I didn’t hold back. Unfortunately, that was also my undoing. Rallycross times are cumulative like stage rally, not based on an individual hero run like autocross. My more balls-to-the-wall driving style was faster than Michael, but I was also more careless and hit more cones, which handed him the win by just 2.006 seconds for the day. Before we even knew who won he already said he wanted a rematch in the future. I’ll be happy to give him one. I even have some leads on true gravel rally tires since we’d be running in Modified class anyway…

Follow @justinhughes54